From our Rugby Coach Weekly archive of Touchline Tales, commenting on a game in an U15 Cup tournament. Last weekend we lost 20-22 in a cup game. The opposition scored at the end from a disputed lineout on our line and we felt our jumper was impeded. MORE
Touchline tales returns while others are leaving the game
I’ve not written a Touchline Tale for a while now. But thanks in particular to Chris Sweetapple’s prompting, I’m going to revive my weekly blog on the world of rugby, learning and coaching.
It’s not that I’ve been short of topics. But I felt it was high time to start chatting about some of the issues of the day.
Christian Wade squeezes through three defenders
Chris told me that it had been a big week for players leaving rugby for pastures new. Not only had Christian Wade, the former Wasps and sometimes England winger, turned his attention to NFL, but Chris’s U16s team captain had decided to put his efforts into boxing.
And then Matt Dawson, England’s World Cup winning scrum half posts this on Twitter…
I’d love to say I remember it well but he knocked me in to the next day…. I played on for 10/15 mins calling all my club moves… unfortunately I do fear there’ll be plenty of consequences in the long term for me. #brutalgame #notformykids https://t.co/qRhRoX3mPI
— Matt Dawson (@matt9dawson) October 31, 2018
The perpetrator of the tackle was Corne Krige, the South African skipper on the day. I was at the match. It was the most brutal game of rugby I’ve ever seen. Krige has since apologised for his behaviour. But Dawson still says: #brutalgame and #notformykids.
I don’t think rugby is as violent as this anymore. It is certainly a tough game with plenty of chances for injury. But, is it still a game for all shapes and sizes? Christian Wade is a diminutive, yet effective winger. He has scored many outstanding tries. It’s also perceived that he’s too small for the international stage, and hence he’s decided to go to another sport for more recognition.
I think the focus on size is very much something at the top end of the game. However, it does drive some very muddle-headed thinking at lower levels. Especially at academies and the surrounding feeder clubs, strength and conditioning plays a big part in the weekly routine. So, if that’s say two to three hours a week on pure conditioning, that’s two to three hours a week where the player is not playing this sport or indeed any other sport.
Okay, the players need to be fit and strong. However, I keep hearing about players who are doing an hour’s work at the gym before they go to school. In my mind, that’s disruptive for the child, and for the families who want to support them.
One of the major reasons that children drop out of sport is that they are bored. They want to spend more time “hanging out”. Or they just want some variety. I know plenty of coaches who’ve been with their teams since the U6s. By the time they are U13s, that seven years of Sunday mornings in the winter. Who doesn’t mind a lie on a Sunday once in a while?
If players spent a little less time in the gym, then it wouldn’t be about size. The collisions would less impactful. There will still be a few mad folk about, like the Springbok captain back in the day. But, given that, how about shorter seasons and a month off from the game in the middle of the season. Just train to play a couple of times a week and only once if you are under 13.
I don’t think it will catch on. I do think more players, and coaches, will leave the sport though.