Gavin Mortimer says that rugby is as bad as soccer these days and that’s despite the recent ridiculous antics in the soccer World Cup. With a heavy heart, I agree.
In a recent article in The Spectator, a rugby writer Gavin Mortimer suggested that rugby no longer had the moral high ground over football. He suggested, despite some of the recent antics of certain football World Cup players, rugby was just as bad.
Uruguay’s Agustin Ormaechea clashes with Fiji’s Campese Ma’afu before being shown a red card Reuters / Stefan Wermuth Livepic
He was right, to a certain degree. Anyone who has played competitive rugby will know that. There’s plenty of skullduggery, violence and abuse. And, there are a number of advocates saying the game has gone soft. Even now, to prevent “cheats” from stopping the release of the ball at the tackle, there are still calls for “rucking” to be reintroduced.
Rucking is where the boot is used to drag the player off the ball. That’s right, six metal studs, on the back, arms and legs of the prone body. Woe betides a boot that goes into the face.
At least there’s an agreement that anything to the face is illegal. Yet gouging, as it’s known, still happens, and if your game isn’t filmed from multiple angles, it’s easier to get away with.
Putting the violence to one side, it’s argued that the two main points of difference between the two sports are simulation and referee abuse.
Simulation is where a player “fakes” an incident to gain an advantage for their team.
These aren’t so prevalent in rugby. It still happens. Anything which approaches a high tackle will often see the ball carrier go down like they’ve been yanked back by an invisible rope. It can buy penalties and even yellow cards.
However, there’s no doubt that most players don’t want to show any signs of pain or weakness on the pitch. We won’t see some of the pathetic rolls or cries of pain on a rugby field for some small clip of the heels.
Referee abuse is another matter. Rugby certainly falls into the passive-aggressive mold here. Players are constantly talking to the referee, disingenuously adding “sir” to their comments. Yet, a poor decision is rarely met with an in-yer-face argument. If that does happen, we all know the consequences. Penalties, marched back 10 metres, or yellow and ultimately red cards.
Portugal’s Cristiano Ronaldo reacts at referee Cesar Arturo Ramos REUTERS/Toru Hanai
But it’s not the players I’m so concerned about. The sidelines abuse is appalling. To say it’s pathetic is a weak view. Frankly, it’s tantamount to the worst sort of schoolyard bullying. What can the referee do? They can’t respond. They just have to take it.
So, while rugby has some moral high ground on the pitch, I’m with Gavin overall. Let’s grow up, stop acting like spoilt kids and start living the behaviours that rugby stands for.
Sarah Cottingham, teacher educator and Educational Neuroscience MA, challenges us on how we think we learn and how we might apply it to our coaching.
Dan Cottrell provides the rugby examples. MORE
It is interesting to reflect on the impact of famous author Dorothy L. Sayers on modern coaching. Way back in 1947, she challenged teachers to make their students think deeper and think more, so they learn for themselves. MORE
In my previous article, I outlined how I set up my Veo for games and training.
I've now had a greater opportunity to use it for recording games.
Again, I come at this without much recent experience of using video analysis software. I don't have much time to sit down and code games. Instead, I will mainly use the footage to pick out some key points to help inform my coaching and to share moments with the players. MORE
This article comes from Alan Zondagh LinkedIn account. It is discussed by Alan with Phil Llewellyn in a Roundup Rodeo special, with guests Ian Costello and Nick Wood. Former Bulls Director of Rugby and seasoned South African coach Alan Zondagh believes the sport is in need of a drastic overall change. My rugby journey started... MORE
A book review of Ulitmate Crush: Waseda University Rugby, Leadership and Building the Strongest Winning Team in Japan Katsuyuki Kiyomiya translated by Ian Ruxton.
The Japanese love slogans.
Ultimate Crush, which was coined for the Waseda University rugby team, translates differently according to the dialect used*, but the core meaning of “overwhelming victory” is clear. MORE
Don’t leave key decisions on your day-to-day coaching to chance. If you think you will be able to use common sense when something happens, you could be fooling yourself. MORE