Did Warren Gatland pick the right players for the British and Irish Lions summer tour to South Africa?
His team of selectors will have been looking at balance and the style that they want to play. They might not pick the best players but more likely combinations that will complement each other.
But, while I have enormous sympathy for the players who were on the edge of the making the cut but missed out, I also recognise that the announcement and fallout is a tough gig for the coaches too.
When I looked after my son’s grassroots team until he was 16, we always rotated equally apart from about three or four occasions. Those times stick in my mind because the conversations with the parents were as tough as the ones with the players.
On a professional level, a Lions tour place the ultimate feather in a players’ cap. And financially, it is extremely lucrative as well.
So, when the coach shares the news, good or bad, they are also sharing the experience the player is having. I can remember have two very good 9s who were vying for the international starting spot for the Wales Women team. The post-selection call on a Monday afternoon to tell one of them they were on the bench was never easy.
The best advice I received was that you have to remember you are picking a team, not a player. As long as your selection is not a personal decision, then it is a performance decision so you can justify your actions.
The player should disagree! But that should be expected if they are competitive enough. However, you are simply trying to pick the right team for this match.
Good luck all the players and coaches involved today. I’m looking forward to a competitive tour and positive rugby.
Here are some ideas to consider around selection issues:
Identifying the players to fulfil your vision is arguably a coach’s most crucial role. Your approach to selection establishes the values of the environment you’re trying to create. Read on to get it right… MORE
Selecting a squad for a season from trials is fraught with difficulties, but is a necessary evil to have a workable size for a team to function during the season. There are other methods, yet there aren't always possible unless you have a long trial period before final selection.
Here's a guide to help you make the most of this opportunity. MORE
There must be a selection chair to run the meeting. He sets out the criteria clearly before the meeting starts and keeps the meeting on message. This requires a tough line with the power to stop someone talking if they move away from the point. MORE
Telling a rugby player he is picked for the team is one of the best parts of the job of being a coach. Telling them they are dropped is probably the worst. This should help you break bad news. MORE
The make-up of your squad is a wide variety of abilities and personalities, which is good because you don’t want clones. But there are always a few players who can be disruptive and affect the learning experience for the group – here’s how to stop this…
MORE
Peak Height Velocity measurements can reduce the number of assumptions you make about the current development stage of your players and help you help them with training programmes. MORE
I wanted to share my experience of developing my coaching, based on making changes as things went well or went wrong. It's a very personal journey of how I developed as a coach myself. MORE
If our players communicated more effectively, then the ball carrier would know when to pass or when to take contact.
Create more opportunities for this to happen by making it matter. The best exercises provide chances for players to see the value in calling for the ball.
Here are four good activities to use. MORE
Leading coaching researchers gives us an insight into how we can improve our coaching and therefore our players’ learning. Here’s a summary of their findings.
Richard L. Light and Stephan Harvey, two of the most respected boffins in sports coaching produced an important paper Positive Pedagogy for sport and coaching, in the Sport, Education and Society journal. MORE
